Posted By Colum Lynch Share

The Indian foreign ministry has once again expressed concern about what it views as inappropriate airport searches of its senior U.S.-based diplomats after its envoy to the U.N., Hardeep Singh Puri, was briefly detained at an airport in Austin, Texas, for refusing to remove his turban, U.N.-based diplomats told Turtle Bay.

This morning's disclosure of the November 13 incident in the Indian press follows previous Indian complaints over the treatment of India's U.S. ambassador, Meera Shankar, who was given a pat down earlier this month at a Mississippi airport despite her claims of diplomatic immunity.

U.S. Secretary of State Hillary R. Clinton, expressed regret over that incident. "We obviously are concerned about it," she told reporters last week. "We will be looking into it and trying to determine both what happened, and what we could do to prevent such incidents in the future."

U.S. officials said that while foreign diplomats enjoy diplomatic immunity during their official assignments in the country they are subject to the intrusive security searches imposed by the Transportation Security Administration. But the practice had led airport security officers to target individuals that wear national garb. Shankar was reportedly singled out because she was dressed in an Indian Sari.

India's Prime Minister Manmohan Singh also wears a turban, which is an integral part of Sikh males' religious, social and cultural identity. Sikh men, who do not cut their hair, are obliged to wear them in public. After the 911 terror attacks, U.S. authorities have sought to compel some Sikhs not to wear their turbans for official duty. A New York City Transit cop sued New York City after he was removed from his beat after refusing to remove his turban while on duty. He won the case.

Airport security agents in Austin pulled Singh aside into a an enclosed glass holding room for questioning after he refused a request to remove his turban or allow inspectors to touch it, an Indian official who witnessed the incident told Turtle Bay.  "He said no, you cannot check my turban," according to the Indian official, who spoke on condition of anonymity. "I won't allow you to touch my turban."

The Indian official said Singh offered to touch the turban himself and to allow the security agents to run a check of his hands for traces of explosives, but he said that one security official refused. Singh insisted that the security official had no right to check his turban, citing TSA regulations for searches of foreign diplomats. "Obviously you don't know your own rules. Please check your rules," he told the security agent, according to the Indian official. "The person insisted that he had to do it. He said, 'Don't tell me the rules.'"

The Indian official said that the security officials finally checked the security regulations and issued an apology to the Indian ambassador. He said he was unaware of whether his government had filed an official complaint with the United States over the issue.

A spokesman for the U.S. mission to the United Nations, Mark Kornblau, declined to comment on the specifics of the incident but said the U.S. regretted his treatment."We have a great deal of respect for Amb. Puri and regret any inconvenience this may have caused."

(Update: In an interview with Press Trust of India, Puri sought to dampen the controversy by saying he had not been physically patted down, and that he believed the airport security guards were simply doing their jobs. “No pat down took place,” he said. “I said I would comply with the procedures but did not allow him to touch my turban. The guard was unaware of the new procedures so I told him to go check with his superior officer. The important thing here is that I did not let them touch my turban.”)

 Follow me on Twitter @columlynch

 

SAM FROM CALIFORNIA

12:05 AM ET

December 14, 2010

How long will the new Indo-American alliance last ...

... with Sikhs and women in Saris getting stopped at airports nonstop. India's view will be "China, there they hate us and mistrust us, but at least they let us get onto an airplane without needing to see the inside of our clothing.

 

BILL888

5:41 AM ET

December 14, 2010

Become a Chinese.

As a result of honorary treatment for minorities, a lot of East Indians want to become Chinese citizens through Hong Kong. Whereas in GuangZhou or other Chinese cities, there are a sizable numbers of Africans, Bangladeshis, Pakistanis and East Indians want to be citizens of China.

 

NICOLINO

12:47 AM ET

December 15, 2010

Yes..... China's famed

Yes..... China's famed treatment of minorities.........................................

 

MALICEIT

4:00 AM ET

December 14, 2010

TSA checklist....

Have US couped the country that this person coming from in the last 60 years-> IF yes-> he is a terrorist
IF no-> he is not a terrorist.

 

DDSNAIK

1:28 PM ET

December 14, 2010

Tricky situation, this is

I don't believe that the average TSA employee intends to offend anyone, but doing his/her job doesn't allow for nuance. If he took this Puri at his word of being Sikh, what's to stop a genuine evildoer from making the same claim and crying diplomatic immunity or invoking cultural sensitivities to avoid a proper security screening ?

Offering to show the security officials the turban himself and downplaying the incidence afterwards was astute of Puri, but we can't have it both ways. Yet another ridiculous example of the nuisance that is political correctness, TSA are asked to be thorough and keep us safe but with one hand metaphorically tied behind their back.

The temptation is to remind those that decline a pat down and the scanners and so on at airports is that flying is a choice and not an entitlement. I have no doubt that arguments to the contrary and in defense of cultural and personal sensitivities will follow, but a counterproposal of effective security procedures would be infinitely more welcome than knee-jerk criticisms and finger pointing.

 

UNFORGIVABLEBLACKNESS

10:59 PM ET

December 15, 2010

What's tricky about it?

you have a foreign diplomat who has diplomatic immunity and who I'm sure can verify it as well as ways for the TSA agents to verify it. It's ridiculous that they aren't given the same level of respect that a U.S. Diplomat would be given.

 

PAUL HPC

3:53 PM ET

December 14, 2010

Not a tricky situation; TSA loves to offend foreign officials

This is not a tricky situation; the TSA has a specialty in offending foreign officials who visit our country. The article does not mention it, but India's Civil Aviation Minister (of all people) was questioned while passing through Chicago in September, and this made national news in India. This would be equivalent of head of the TSA (Pistole) being profiled and questioned as possible terrorist when visiting another country. What is the net result of all these incidents? It humiliates and offends foreign officials, ends up on the front pages of newspapers in India (and other countries), and offends millions of readers who see the U.S. as bigoted and stupid.

The TSA, Homeland Security seem to have no clue how asinine they are when they do this. Instead, they leave it to the State Department to go around cleaning up the mess they leave everywhere. The TSA is not making America safer by questing India's Civil Aviation Minister. Instead, they are showing how they are so utterly stupid and clueless and alienating people in other countries that we need as allies. Pistole should apologize himself to every foreign official his agents have offended. If the Golden Rule applies, then he and other TSA officials should be singled out for extra-careful scrutiny everytime they visit a foreign country. Or maybe he should just resign or be fired.

 

WILDTHING

7:42 PM ET

December 14, 2010

No admittance

If they find something inside the turban that can think it will not be allowed into our country for fear it might spread to our people.

 

HOMOSAPIENS

8:55 PM ET

December 14, 2010

What goes around comes around.........

Americans can only blame their national character as a warrior nation for all this security crap. When we stop killing people around the world, they willl stop trying to kill us. If you vote for someone who likes war, well then, take off your shoes and belt, and let the guy poke you all over. You asked for it.

 

EDWARD J. P. GALLAGHER

9:22 PM ET

December 14, 2010

AMEN!!

AMEN!!

 

EDWARD J. P. GALLAGHER

9:22 PM ET

December 14, 2010

AMEN!!

AMEN!!

 

ONLOOKER

7:03 PM ET

December 15, 2010

Common sense

Surely it is not that difficult for TSA to obtain from the State department details of senior personnel with pictures from each of the Embassies on US soil.

 

Longtime Washington Post correspondent Colum Lynch reports on all things United Nations for Turtle Bay.

Read More